Please try one of the other overloads of the method:
Also confirm that a user with that username exists in Sitefinity by trying to login using the default backend login. Please also let us know on what version of Sitefinity are you experiencing the problem?
Furthermore, if possible, please provide us with the complete stack trace of the exception from the error logs so we can see exactly where the problem happens.
Do you want to have your say in the Sitefinity development roadmap? Do you want to know when a feature you requested is added or when a bug fixed? Explore the Telerik Sitefinity CMS Ideas&Feedback Portal
and vote to affect the priority of the items